Wisconsin utility regulators have dealt a major procedural blow to the transmission link planned to power a $15 billion data center campus tied to Oracle and OpenAI's Stargate initiative, forcing the project's developer to restart a permitting process that could push full energization into 2029.
The Lighthouse campus, developed by Vantage Data Centers in Port Washington, Wisconsin, is one of the largest single data center investments in the U.S. Midwest. Its power supply hinges on a new transmission project proposed by American Transmission Company (ATC), which in September 2025 filed a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity (CPCN) application with the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (PSCW) for new and upgraded 345 kV and 138 kV lines spanning Calumet, Fond du Lac, Manitowoc, Ozaukee, Sheboygan and Washington counties, along with four to five new substations. The filing was triggered by a request from utility We Energies to connect new load that its existing distribution system could not support.
The commission declared the application complete in December 2025, a determination that set a 180-day deadline for a final decision, extendable to 360 days. But over the following seven months, ATC submitted or resubmitted 564 filings, including route changes, new temporary bypasses and adjustments to engineering scope. PSCW Chair Summer Strand described the result as a "moving-target application" that made review difficult for staff and the public, and in July 2026 the commission's administrative law judge raised concerns about missing and repeatedly changing information. On August 6, 2026, all three commissioners voted to withdraw the completeness determination and close the case, neither rejecting nor approving the project itself. "This application was clearly near drowning, and withdrawing completeness was throwing it a life ring," Strand said, adding that the decision would affect construction schedules and in-service dates. Commissioner Marcus Hawkins called it "the least bad option," while Commissioner Kristy Nieto stressed that "the credibility of our decisions depends not only on the outcome but on the integrity of the process by which we reach it." According to Wisconsin Public Radio, ATC and a ratepayer watchdog group said the step appeared to be the first of its kind in decades, and possibly ever.
ATC refiled on September 14, 2026, with a revised cost estimate of $2.48 billion to $2.72 billion depending on the route selected, up roughly $1 billion at both ends of the range from the earlier $1.39 billion to $1.67 billion. The largest new item is an approximately $1.1 billion system at the planned Decker substation to smooth grid fluctuations caused by the Oracle data center, accounting for about 40% of the new cost and explicitly funded by Oracle so that "related costs will not be borne by other customers." ATC's filing adds an E-STATCOM, a power-electronics device that supports voltage and system reliability. Tom Content, executive director of the Wisconsin Citizens Utility Board, noted that data center load fluctuates sharply within a day, a pattern that has raised reliability concerns in states such as Virginia and Texas, but said the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission will ultimately decide whether Oracle truly bears the $1.1 billion. "Our biggest concern is whether data center-related costs will ultimately be charged accurately and fully to the data centers," he said. The revised application also designates a South East route as preferred and a South West route as alternate, removes an east-west segment through the towns of Trenton and Saukville, and maximizes use of existing corridors. "The need for this project has not changed; what has changed is the application itself," said Jared Winters, ATC executive vice president and chief asset officer. The procedural clock resets entirely, with public comment schedules to follow only after a new completeness determination, and the project must also clear review by the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources.
The scale of the power demand explains the scrutiny. The Lighthouse campus spans 672 acres with four data centers designed for about 902 MW of critical IT load at full capacity and roughly 2.5 million square feet of building area, according to Data Center Dynamics citing Vantage. Content told WPR that phase one alone requires about 1,300 MW, with future demand potentially reaching 3,500 MW, compared with We Energies' current largest customer at under 100 MW. "To put it bluntly, this is like moving 35 steel mills onto farmland north of Port Washington," he said. On cost allocation, the PSCW unanimously approved a special We Energies tariff for extra-large customers in April 2026 after extending the contract term to 15 years, lowering the eligibility threshold to 100 MW with mandatory participation and removing an option that would have let data centers pay only 75% of new generation costs. "Wisconsin's existing customers should not pay a penny of subsidy — not now, not decades from now," Nieto said at the time. ATC said campus customers have committed to pay their own electricity costs and to fully fund the transmission infrastructure through rates, while Vantage's Mark Freeman said the campus "will be paid for by Vantage and our customers, Oracle and OpenAI."
Public opposition had been building well before the vote, with more than 2,000 comments submitted since July 2026 on the application, route and completeness determination. Patti Plough, who leads a coalition of residents from Saukville, Trenton, Fredonia and Farmington, said she was "thrilled but the fight is not over," while Tom Stolp of the land trust Restoring Lands said he was encouraged that ATC's revised application avoids the original preferred route through permanently conserved land. Construction at the campus has continued regardless: OpenAI, Oracle and Vantage announced the site in October 2025, site work began in the second half of 2025, and the second data center topped out in November 2026, with Vantage projecting about 5,000 construction workers at peak and more than 1,000 permanent jobs. But the power timeline remains unresolved. ATC had hoped to begin construction in December 2026 and complete the transmission facilities by the end of 2027; officials now estimate the review could take a year, followed by about 17 months of construction. Freeman emphasized that the campus's emergency diesel generators "are not an operational plan that can be used to fill the gap," leaving no clear answer on when Lighthouse will be able to run at full power.
